Proxy Comparison 2025

Providers Compared: 50+ | Last Updated: November 2024 | Interactive Tables

Stop wasting time researching. Compare all major proxy providers side-by-side: pricing, features, IP pools, success rates, and real user reviews.

🎯 Quick Comparison: Top 5 Providers

Feature Bright Data Smartproxy Proxy6 Oxylabs Webshare
Rating ⭐ 4.8/5 🎁 4.7/5 💰 4.7/5 ⭐ 4.8/5 🎁 4.6/5
Type Residential Residential Datacenter Residential Datacenter
IP Pool 72M+ 40M+ 1M+ 100M+ 10M+
Price/GB $8.40-12.75 $4-8.50 N/A $8+ N/A
Price/Proxy N/A $5 static $0.60 IPv6 N/A $1.38
Countries 195 195 21 195 10
Success Rate 95%+ 90-95% 85%+ 95%+ 80-90%
Free Trial No 7 days No No 1GB Free
Best For Enterprise Beginners MMO/Budget E-Commerce Testing
Try Now Try → Try → Try → Try → Try →

📊 Complete Comparison Tables

Residential Proxies Comparison

Provider Rating Pool Size Price/GB Countries Rotation City Targeting Trial/Refund
Bright Data 4.8/5 72M+ $8.40 195 Yes Yes 7-day refund
Smartproxy 4.7/5 40M+ $4-8.50 195 Yes Yes 7-day trial
Oxylabs 4.8/5 100M+ $8 195 Yes Yes Custom
Soax 4.6/5 5M+ $6.60 85+ Yes Limited Refund
IPRoyal 4.5/5 2M+ $1.75 195 Yes No Refund

Winner: Oxylabs for pool size, Smartproxy for value

Datacenter Proxies Comparison

Provider Rating Pool Size IPv4 Price IPv6 Price Bandwidth Locations Trial
Proxy6 4.7/5 1M+ $1.77 $0.60 Unlimited 21 No
Webshare 4.6/5 10M+ $1.38 N/A Metered 10 1GB Free
IPRoyal 4.5/5 N/A $1.75 N/A Unlimited 195 No

Winner: Proxy6 for IPv6, Webshare for free tier

ISP Proxies Comparison

Provider Rating Price/IP/Month Bandwidth Locations Min Duration
Smartproxy ISP 4.7/5 $5 Unlimited 7 countries 30 days
Bright Data ISP 4.8/5 $15 Unlimited 10+ countries Custom
Oxylabs ISP 4.8/5 Contact Unlimited Limited Custom

Winner: Smartproxy for affordability

Mobile Proxies Comparison

Provider Rating Price/GB 4G/5G Locations Rotation
Bright Data Mobile 4.8/5 $20 Both Global Yes
Smartproxy Mobile 4.7/5 $25 Both 195 countries Yes
Soax Mobile 4.6/5 Included 4G Limited Yes

Winner: Bright Data for price, Smartproxy for coverage

💰 Pricing Comparison Calculator

Residential Proxies - Cost per 100GB

Provider 10GB 50GB 100GB 500GB Best Deal
Bright Data $127.50 $637.50 $1,050 $4,200 $8.40/GB (500GB)
Smartproxy $85 $425 $400 $2,000 $4/GB (100GB)
Oxylabs $80 $400 $800 Contact Custom pricing
Soax $99 $399 $660 $3,300 $6.60/GB (100GB)
IPRoyal $17.50 $87.50 $175 $875 $1.75/GB (any)

Budget Winner: IPRoyal ($175 for 100GB) Premium Winner: Smartproxy ($400 for 100GB, best value)

Datacenter Proxies - Cost per 100 Proxies/Month

Provider IPv4 (10) IPv4 (100) IPv6 (100) Bulk Discount
Proxy6 $17.70 $177 → $123.90 $60 → $42 30% off 100+
Webshare FREE* $138 N/A Volume pricing
IPRoyal $17.50 $175 N/A Contact

*1GB free = ~10 proxies

Budget Winner: Proxy6 IPv6 ($42 for 100 proxies) Free Winner: Webshare (1GB free)

🆚 Head-to-Head Comparisons

Proxy6 vs Webshare (Budget Battle)

Feature Proxy6 Webshare Winner
Price $0.60 IPv6, $1.77 IPv4 FREE 1GB, $1.38 IPv4 Webshare (free)
Pool Size 1M+ 10M+ Webshare
IPv6 Support ✅ Yes ❌ No Proxy6
Bulk Discount ✅ 30% off ❌ No Proxy6
Best For MMO farming (100+ accounts) Testing, small projects Depends

Verdict: Webshare for testing/free, Proxy6 for bulk/MMO

Full Comparison →

Bright Data vs Smartproxy (Premium Battle)

Feature Bright Data Smartproxy Winner
Pool Size 72M 40M Bright Data
Price/GB $8.40 $4-8.50 Smartproxy
Ease of Use Complex Beginner-friendly Smartproxy
Success Rate 95%+ 90-95% Bright Data
Free Trial No (7-day refund) 7 days Smartproxy
Support Good Excellent Smartproxy

Verdict: Bright Data for enterprise/performance, Smartproxy for ease/value

Full Comparison →

Residential vs Datacenter Proxies

Feature Residential Datacenter Best Choice
Trust Level ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ Residential
Success Rate 95%+ 60-85% Residential
Speed 100-300ms 10-50ms Datacenter
Price $8-15/GB $0.60-3/proxy Datacenter
Best For Sneakers, Instagram, E-comm MMO, Testing, SEO Depends
Ban Rate <5% 15-30% Residential

Verdict: Residential for high-value, Datacenter for budget/speed

Full Comparison →

IPv4 vs IPv6 Proxies

Feature IPv4 IPv6 Winner
Compatibility 100% sites ~70% sites IPv4
Price $1.77 $0.60 IPv6 (70% cheaper)
Availability Limited Abundant IPv6
Instagram Support ✅ ✅ Tie
E-Commerce Support ✅ ⚠️ Mixed IPv4
Best For Universal compatibility Budget MMO Depends

Verdict: IPv6 for budget MMO (Instagram, TikTok), IPv4 for universal use

Full Comparison →

🎯 Comparison by Use Case

Best for Sneaker Copping

Rank Provider Price Pool Success Rate Speed Verdict
🥇 Bright Data $$$ 72M 95%+ Fast Best overall
🥈 Smartproxy $$ 40M 90-95% Good Best value
🥉 Oxylabs $$$ 100M 95%+ Fast Enterprise

Budget: $100-500/month | Proxies Needed: 50-100

Best for Instagram Automation

Rank Provider Type Price Trust Level Ban Rate Verdict
🥇 Soax Mobile+Res $6.60/GB Very High <5% Best for IG
🥈 Smartproxy Static ISP $5/IP High <5% Good value
🥉 Proxy6 IPv6 Datacenter $0.60 Medium ~10% Budget

Budget: $50-200/month (10-50 accounts) | Ratio: 1 proxy per 5-10 accounts

Best for MMO & Account Farming

Rank Provider Type Price Accounts Cost/Account Verdict
🥇 Proxy6 IPv6 Datacenter $0.60 100+ $0.42 Ultra cheap
🥈 Proxy6 IPv4 Datacenter $1.77 100+ $1.24 Standard
🥉 Webshare Datacenter $1.38 Small $1.38 Free tier

Budget: $20-100/month (50-500 accounts)

Best for E-Commerce Scraping

Rank Provider Pool Price Success Rate E-Comm Features Verdict
🥇 Oxylabs 100M $8/GB 95%+ Built-in scrapers Best for Amazon
🥈 Bright Data 72M $8.40/GB 95%+ Data collector Most reliable
🥉 Smartproxy 40M $4/GB 90-95% Good coverage Best value

Budget: $200-1,000/month

Best for Web Scraping

Rank Provider Pool Price/GB Rotation Bandwidth Verdict
🥇 Bright Data 72M $8.40 Excellent Unlimited Best overall
🥈 Oxylabs 100M $8 Excellent Unlimited Largest pool
🥉 IPRoyal 2M $1.75 Good Unlimited Budget option

Budget: $100-500/month

🏆 Best Proxy Awards 2025

Overall Categories

🥇 Best Overall Proxy Provider

💰 Best Budget Provider

🎁 Best Free Tier

⭐ Best for Beginners

🏢 Best Enterprise Solution

Use Case Categories

👟 Best for Sneaker Copping

📱 Best for Social Media

💰 Best for MMO/Account Farming

🛒 Best for E-Commerce Scraping

🔍 Best for SEO Tools

🔧 Feature Comparison Matrix

Advanced Features

Feature Bright Data Smartproxy Proxy6 Oxylabs Webshare
Rotating IPs ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
Static IPs ✅ ✅ ISP ✅ ✅ ✅
City Targeting ✅ ✅ ❌ ✅ ❌
Session Control ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
API Access ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
Bandwidth Rollover ❌ ❌ N/A ❌ ❌
IPv6 Support ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌
SOCKS5 ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
Residential ✅ ✅ ❌ ✅ ❌
Datacenter ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
ISP ✅ ✅ ❌ ✅ ❌
Mobile ✅ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌

Support & Documentation

Feature Bright Data Smartproxy Proxy6 Oxylabs Webshare
24/7 Live Chat ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ❌
Email Support ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
Phone Support ✅ Enterprise ❌ ❌ ✅ Enterprise ❌
Documentation ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Video Tutorials ✅ ✅ ⚠️ Limited ✅ ⚠️ Limited
Account Manager ✅ Enterprise ❌ ❌ ✅ Enterprise ❌

💡 How to Compare Proxies

Key Factors to Consider

1. Success Rate (Most Important)

2. Speed

3. IP Pool Size

4. Geographic Coverage

5. Pricing Structure

6. Support Quality

🎯 Decision Matrix

Choose Based on Budget & Use Case

Budget Sneakers Instagram MMO E-Commerce Web Scraping
<$50 N/A Proxy6 Proxy6 N/A Webshare
$50-200 Smartproxy Smartproxy Proxy6 IPRoyal IPRoyal
$200-500 Smartproxy Soax Smartproxy Smartproxy Smartproxy
$500+ Bright Data Bright Data Bright Data Oxylabs Bright Data

📈 Success Rate Comparison

Real-World Testing Results

Sneaker Sites (Shopify, Footsites)

Instagram Automation

E-Commerce (Amazon, eBay)

Web Scraping (General)

❓ FAQ

Which proxy provider is cheapest?

Proxy6 - IPv6 proxies at $0.60/month. For residential, IPRoyal at $1.75/GB.

Which has the largest IP pool?

Oxylabs - 100M+ residential IPs. Followed by Bright Data (72M+) and Smartproxy (40M+).

Which is best for beginners?

Smartproxy - Easiest dashboard, 7-day trial, excellent support. Alternative: Webshare for free testing.

Residential or datacenter for Instagram?

Residential or ISP. Datacenter works but has higher ban rate (~10-15%). Use Soax mobile or Smartproxy static.

Can I try before buying?

Yes:

🔗 Related Comparisons

All Resources

Tools

Last Updated: November 2024 | Comparison Data Updated Monthly

Need Help Deciding? Use our interactive comparison tool → or contact us for personalized recommendations.